Subscribe | Give a Gift | Subscription Customer Service
How We Are Different Order Back Issues Interactive Glossary Weblog Contact the Staff Subscribe to Woodworking Magazine

Woodworking Magazine Weblog

Posted 4/9/2008 in All Weblog Posts | Boring

The best hand drills ever made came out of the Millers Falls factory in the first half of the 20th century. While many people used these drills for boring holes in metal, the tools proved remarkably adept at becoming the first generation of cordless drills for woodworking.

These drills are today called eggbeater drills because of the way the drive mechanism works. The main gear turns either one or two pinions on the tool’s shaft to turn the chuck backward or forward – just like an old kitchen eggbeater.

My favorite eggbeater drills are the Nos. 2, 2A and 5 made by Millers Falls. These drills were made to an astonishingly high degree of precision, and are easily comparable to tools manufactured today by Lie-Nielsen Toolworks, Veritas, Wenzloff & Sons, Adria or Gramercy.

The eggbeater drills are fairly common at flea markets, but they are also usually in dogmeat shape. The gears are rusted. The bearings are gummed up. The wood knobs are dried out and cracked. The frames have lost all their paint.

But now Wiktor Kuc, the owner of WKTools.com and WKFineTools.com, is restoring and selling these drills on his website and on eBay. He recently sent me a Millers Falls No. 5 that he has restored, and I am just stunned by the quality of the restoration.

This tool looks better than any example of a Millers Falls I’ve ever seen. It looks good no matter how close you examine it. Inside the chuck. At the seam between the ferrule and the handle. Where the pinions mesh with the main gear.

Kuc says he’s been restoring these kinds of drills for a year. He’s been learning the best way to disassemble and clean the tools, how to apply principles from jewelers to polish the metalwork, and how to deal with the dried-out wood.

“I started doing this for myself,” Kuc says. “I love to restore old tools. I read Herb Keane’s book (‘Restoring Antique Tools’) and it blew my roof off. I had to learn to do that.”

Since he started restoring drills (and some braces), Kuc’s resurrected more than 130 Millers Falls drills, 30 Goodell-Pratt drills and a number of braces.

He takes all the drills apart as much as possible, strips them clean and then rebuilds them so they look and work perfectly. The ones he can restore to their full glory Kuc sells on his web site after four to five coats of paint and refinishing everything. The drills that he cannot get perfect he sells on eBay at a reduced price, though they are functionally perfect.

The perfect drills cost between $60 and $110, depending on their rarity. On eBay, the current crop of drills cost between $50 and $90. Are they worth it? Absolutely. If you want a cordless drill that will never run out of juice (until you run out of juice) an eggbeater like this is ideal for any toolbox.

These tools have small chucks that are great for furniture-scale twists and brad-point bits. I use hand drills all the time when making pilot holes, especially for screws or nails.

And one more thing: If you already have a Millers Falls drill, Kuc also sells reproduction parts for these drills that are usually missing, such as the side knobs and the bits that are stored in the handles.

Millers Falls drills are very common, so if you don’t want a restored one you’ll be able to find them at garage sales, flea markets and eBay (they are not scarce by any measure). But if you want the best – a tool that looks as good as it works, check out Kuc’s selection. Highly recommended by me (and banned by wivesagainstschwarz.com).

— Christopher Schwarz


4/10/2008 7:20:57 AM (Eastern Daylight Time, UTC-04:00)
OMG these are beautifully restored, a real work of art!
Never been too much fond of over restoration, but these are, like you said the best hand drill ever made, and most found are dogmeat. I own a 'few' myself, and I used them, but wow, these brings tears of joy to my eyes. Bravo Kuc. So currently we have first class handsaws, planes, spokeshaves, and now hand drills, and comming up soon braces. Its never been a better time to be a hand tool WW than the present.

Thank you, thank you, thank you
Bob, having a hard time to peel myself off the pictures on the screen to go to work :-)
4/10/2008 7:52:17 AM (Eastern Daylight Time, UTC-04:00)
I own half a dozen of these puppies. Two are in near perfect condition [#5 & #2B], two more that work but have cosmetic issues while the rest are for parts. Oh and I have a nice Goodell-Pratt too. I love working with these and use them almost exclusively for countersinks where precision is needed. Chuck a single flute counter sink in one and you're guaranteed to avoid chatter. Sweet.

I also will use [just for fun] a Millers-Falls chest brace. Call me crazy.

always,
J.C.
4/10/2008 10:34:34 AM (Eastern Daylight Time, UTC-04:00)
Wiktor has restored several of these drills for me. The quality you see in the pictures is the same quality I have gotten on all the drills he restored. First class work! I highly recommend him (but don't start lining up for him until he finishes 3 more for me !! :-)).

It is a joy to use these drills. I keep several with bits chucked that I use all the time. It saves time and they are a delight to use.

Mike Doster
4/10/2008 10:49:50 AM (Eastern Daylight Time, UTC-04:00)
Now, Chris, you're being too hard on yourself when you tag this story as "boring." Sure, it's no potboiler, but it's not much worse than the rest of your dreck...

John Kuszewski
4/10/2008 12:31:47 PM (Eastern Daylight Time, UTC-04:00)
Chris - It's worth mentioning to your readers that Wiktor's service (and restored drills) is a great thing for something you wish to use in the shop everyday. That said, however, those that have a Miller-Falls in good shape should consider very carefully whether they wish to have it restored, because such restoration destroys the value (completely) as a collector's item. It's unlikely that a good condition Miller Falls will bring much money from the collector's market, with one big exception, and that is if you have the original box and instructions. I've personally seen one of these go for $400 with these accoutrements, even though the tool itself had rust, discoloration of the metal parts, and a tight check in the handle.

There are a very large number of antique tool collectors and users that think a much better title for Herb Keane's book is "How to Ruin Antique Tools". In a parallel to the antique furniture and collectible market, original surfaces and condition is critically important to tools as historical artifacts.
4/10/2008 1:13:21 PM (Eastern Daylight Time, UTC-04:00)
Apparently due to this article all the drills on the website are now sold.
4/10/2008 1:25:49 PM (Eastern Daylight Time, UTC-04:00)

David,

I would agree with you completely if this were about 18th century plows. But we're talking about some of the most common drills of their era. These drills will continue to surface from basements for another hundred years. And what I should have mentioned in the article is that Wiktor doesn't restore the pristine stuff that should be in a collection. So I'm really glad you brought up this point!

Chris
4/10/2008 3:11:38 PM (Eastern Daylight Time, UTC-04:00)
Cris F - And all of them on e-bay. Happily for those that already have one, and sadly for those that don't, tool recommendations carry a lot of weight. Stanley 42X saw sets, for example, sell for nearly 3 times what a 42 or a 43 does, primarily because Pete Tarran states that the 42X is the best out there (I wouldn't disagree, it's just that I fall in the "sad" lot as described above!).
4/10/2008 3:14:59 PM (Eastern Daylight Time, UTC-04:00)

This is probably the third time since 2004 that I've praised these models of drills. Sure, there's a short-term shortage, but there is a very long-term supply. I see these drills at every old tool show.

Patience!

Chris
4/10/2008 3:15:41 PM (Eastern Daylight Time, UTC-04:00)
Chris - Also worth mentioning - The edict about not refinishing tools in good original shape extends all the way to WWII. It would be a very bad financial mistake to refinish/rejapan a Stanley #1 bench plane unless it's completely and totally trashed. Refinishing any boxwood or (especially) ivory rule is bad news, as it typically totally destroys the rule's value. Many of Miller Falls tools fall into this category, among them Permaloid-handled bit braces, "Buck Rodgers" handplanes, and the eggbeater drills with the original documentation.
4/12/2008 1:27:18 PM (Eastern Daylight Time, UTC-04:00)
I was going to order one of these, but dang it all.

Maybe some day :(
4/12/2008 10:53:22 PM (Eastern Daylight Time, UTC-04:00)
I bought one of these drills from Wiktor last fall for my young son for Christmas. It was the perfect gift... he loves using it and I consider it a wonderful and safe introduction to woodworking for my little 4-year-old. I carefully supervise his use of this classic tool so that he won't abuse it. We used it last weekend when we made a couple of owl houses for Mommy. I plan to add a hand tool every Christmas to his woodworking tool box, just like my Dad did for me!
4/13/2008 9:38:28 AM (Eastern Daylight Time, UTC-04:00)
QuoteCris F - And all of them on e-bay. Happily for those that already have one, and sadly for those that don't, tool recommendations carry a lot of weight. Stanley 42X saw sets, for example, sell for nearly 3 times what a 42 or a 43 does, primarily because Pete Tarran states that the 42X is the best out there (I wouldn't disagree, it's just that I fall in the "sad" lot as described above!).Quote

I hope it will be 10x; than there wll be an opportunity to manufacture new ones with that high standard.
Name
E-mail
Home page

Comment (HTML not allowed)  

Enter the code shown (prevents robots):

 Copyright © 2005 F+W Publications Inc. All rights reserved.